Skip to Main Content

Recognizing Scholarly Sources in History

History is a topic with broad interest that extends beyond history scholars. For this reason, you must pay particular attention to the quality and audience of the sources you will use in your research. Look for substantial sources that clearly display indicators of scholarliness:

  • Authority: Written by a history scholar with an advanced academic credential, published by a reputable academic organization or publisher.
  • Audience: Aimed at an academic audience in the field of History; look for specialized language and formal academic style, format and organization in the writing.
  • Process: The source should be based on substantial original historical research (look for footnotes and bibliography, mention of primary sources), and be peer-reviewed.

Scholarly Sources include

 

Hands On: Quickly skim the sources below, looking for signs of whether the sources are scholarly sources appropriate for use in an academic History paper or not. Based on the evidence you see while skimming, "vote" on whether the sources are appropriate or not. NOTE: You don't have time to read these sources, so skim for clues as quickly as you can, using the indicators mentioned above as your guide.
Yes, this is a scholarly source appropriate for an academic history paper: 6 votes (17.65%)
No, this is not a scholarly source and I would avoid using it in an academic history paper: 19 votes (55.88%)
I am not sure; maybe I would use this, but I wouldn't rely heavily on it: 9 votes (26.47%)
Total Votes: 34
Yes, this is a scholarly source appropriate for an academic history paper: 10 votes (29.41%)
No, this is not a scholarly source and I would avoid using it in an academic history paper: 15 votes (44.12%)
I am not sure; maybe I would use this, but I wouldn't rely heavily on it: 9 votes (26.47%)
Total Votes: 34
Yes, this is a scholarly source appropriate for an academic history paper: 25 votes (78.13%)
No, this is not a scholarly source and I would avoid using it in an academic history paper: 6 votes (18.75%)
I am not sure; maybe I would use this, but I wouldn't rely heavily on it: 1 votes (3.13%)
Total Votes: 32
Yes, this is a scholarly source appropriate for an academic history paper: 6 votes (18.18%)
No, this is not a scholarly source and I would avoid using it in an academic history paper: 21 votes (63.64%)
I am not sure; maybe I would use this, but I wouldn't rely heavily on it: 6 votes (18.18%)
Total Votes: 33
Yes, this is a scholarly source appropriate for an academic history paper: 26 votes (86.67%)
No, this is not a scholarly source and I would avoid using it in an academic history paper: 2 votes (6.67%)
I am not sure; maybe I would use this, but I wouldn't rely heavily on it: 2 votes (6.67%)
Total Votes: 30
Yes, this is a scholarly source appropriate for an academic history paper: 23 votes (69.7%)
No, this is not a scholarly source and I would avoid using it in an academic history paper: 7 votes (21.21%)
I am not sure; maybe I would use this, but I wouldn't rely heavily on it: 3 votes (9.09%)
Total Votes: 33
Yes, this is a scholarly source appropriate for an academic history paper: 25 votes (78.13%)
No, this is not a scholarly source and I would avoid using it in an academic history paper: 2 votes (6.25%)
I am not sure; maybe I would use this, but I wouldn't rely heavily on it: 5 votes (15.63%)
Total Votes: 32

Find Books & Articles Using LibrarySearch

LibrarySearch is the best starting point for finding books and articles at MRU

  • Within the search results, don't overlook items that seem broadly related to your topic. Look at the item descriptions and article abstracts, chapter headings of books, or do quick keyword searches of ebooks to see if your narrower or more specific topic discussed.
  • Put important phrases inside quotation marks e.g., "consumer culture" 
  • Put synonyms inside brackets to search for either one at the same time e.g., (automobiles OR cars) 
     

Pro Tip
For some topics, it can be difficult to find narrow a topic successfully via your search terms. Try limiting your search by selecting Subject from the options on the right side, then choose a relevant subject tag from the list of options.
LlibrarySearch subject filter

 

Pro Tip
Did you know you can lock your filters in place in Library Search? Hover your cursor over the limit and click to look it in place. Now, even if you change your search terms, the limit will stay in place.

Image of option to lock in a filter. Cursor is hovering over the limit and image of lock appears.

History-Specific Journal Article Databases

If you find yourself overwhelmed with results in LibrarySearch you can try some of the following journal article databases which search fewer, but potentially more relevant, journals.

Use the same strategies you used in LibrarySearch, and be sure to use the advanced search options and filters to improve results.

Materials Beyond MRU Library

Primary Sources for Consumer History

Emergence of Advertising in America - Duke University collection of advertisements, 1850-1920.

Smithsonian: Warshaw Collection of Business American a 1724-1977  - Largest advertising ephemera collection in the USA.

Ad*Access - US and Canadian advertisements covering beauty and hygiene, radio, television, transportation and World War II propaganda, 1911-1955.

Consumer Advertising During the Great Depression: A Resource Guide - Covers many different aspects of advertising during this period, including grocery advertising and gender in advertising, 

MRU Library Primary Sources for US History - try the historical newspaper section, the Library of Congress and National Archives links.

 

 

 

Librarian

Profile Photo
Alice Swabey
Contact:
Drop-in help Mondays 12-2 at the Library Service Desk. Appointments available via Google Meet or in-person. Email help is also available.
Email: aswabey@mtroyal.ca