Skip to Main Content

EDUC 2371

Introduction to Critical Literacy

Critical literacy is the term used to refer to a particular aspect of critical thinking.

  • Critical literacy involves looking beyond the literal meaning of a text to determine what is present and what is missing, in order to analyse and evaluate the text’s complete meaning and the author’s intent.
  • Critical literacy is concerned with issues related to fairness, equity, and social justice.

Critically literate students adopt a critical stance, asking what view of the world the text advances and whether they find this view acceptable, who benefits from the text, and how the reader is influenced.  (Ontario Ministry of Education, n.d.)

  • points of view (e.g., those of people from various cultures);
  • context (e.g., the beliefs and practices of the time and place in which a text was created and those in which it is being read or viewed);
  • the background of the person who is interacting with the text (e.g., upbringing, friends, communities, education, experiences/positionality);
  • intertextuality (e.g., information that a reader or viewer brings to a text from other texts experienced previously);
  • gaps in the text (e.g., information that is left out and that the reader or viewer must fill in);
  • silences in the text (e.g., the absence of the voices of certain people or groups).

(Ontario Ministry of Education, n.d.)

Critical Indigenous Literacy:

  • Think about:
    • Authorship and identity in relation to the stories and teachings we trust as reader- Own Voices
    • Character/content representation
    • Misinformation
    • Historical representations

Small Group Activity: 
Review the books 

  1. Review selection of books
  2. Identify content that may reflect stereotypes, racist or gendered/heteronormative thinking
  3. Capture your responses to the following questions:
    • Who wrote this and why?
    • Who benefits most from this text?
    • Does the author share the identity of  the underrepresented/marginalized group represented in the story? Are any voices missing from this text?
    •  How are characters represented in the illustrations and text? (stereotypes, names, complexity etc.)
  4. Consider titles that provide an engaging and relatively in-depth presentation of their topic. Consider titles that do not represent their topic or characters authentically
  5. Choose 2 books to present  in a larger class discussion
  6. Considering the above, and your evaluation, how would you incorporate these books into a lesson plan/unit? How might problematic text be useful in teaching children critical literacy skills?

Are these titles problematic?

Little Black Sambo by Helen Bannerman

A Taste of Colored Water 

Ling and Ting by  Grace Lin

 

What does the Alberta classroom look like?

 

Data about Calgary's population

Calgary school boards assess thousands of refugee students arriving since July
The Calgary Board of Education expects more than 7,000 new students this fall, a number that could rise as more refugees arrive at the CBE Welcome Centre. 

_____________________

2021 Alberta Census Data on Indigenous Peoples
Statistics Canada

_____________________

Alberta government’s population statistics 

Critical Literacy Resources

Articles:
Critical Literacy in Early Elementary Grades  Justine Bruyère Edutopia June 7, 2019

Fostering Culturally Relevant Literacy Instruction: Lessons from a Native Hawaiian Classroom

Seuss, Racism, and Resources for Anti-Racist Children’s Literature

Critical Indigenous Literacy for Children’s Picture Books (A resource from UBC)

Podcast:

CBC Front Bruner - Dr. Seuss, and how to deal with racism in children's classics

Blogs:

AICL - American Indians in Children's Literature. Debbie Reese reviews children's books about Indigenous people
PEN Canada - You can’t read that: Banning kids’ books in Canada and the United States

Calgary Board of Education Guide:

Guidelines for attending to Gender Identity, Gender Expression and Sexual Orientation in our Schools

Books:

Creating Critical Classrooms: reading and writing with an edge by Mitzi Lewison (page 6)
Video:

Librarian

Profile Photo
Pearl Herscovitch
she, her
Contact:
Email: pherscovitch@mtroyal.ca
Phone: 403.440.6022
Office: EL4423B